A Guide to Tuesday’s Supreme Court Hearing on Marriage Equality
Remember, the Justices will not be rendering a decision about marriage rights on Tuesday. They’re just listening to oral arguments presented by gay and lesbian couples (the petitioners) and states that want to deny their marriage rights (the respondents).
The Justices will have an opportunity to question the attorney’s who are representing the petitioners and the respondents. Then they’ll will make their final ruling later this summer.
I’ve written this handy guide to help you understand what is at issue and what to expect to happen that day.
There are actually four separate cases before the Court from four separate states: Ohio, Tennessee, Michigan, and Kentucky.
1. whether the Constitution requires states to allow same-sex couples to marry; and
2. whether the Constitution requires states to recognize the marriages of same-sex couples who were legally married in another state.
These issues are now commonly known as the “marriage” and “recognition” questions.
Each petitioner and respondent is required to file a brief explaining the legal basis for their argument. In addition, there are also over a hundred amicus, or “friend of the court,” briefs filed by individuals and groups who support the petitioners and the respondents. The federal government even filed an amicus brief supporting the petitioners. Is your head spinning yet?
On the day of the hearing the Court may have a few other business matters to attend to before they get to the marriage equality question. For one thing, they may decide to take some time to release their decisions in previously argued cases. They might also hold swearing in ceremonies for new members of the Supreme Court bar. We won’t know for sure if any of this will happen until a day or two before the hearing, but, even if they do, it shouldn’t take too long.
After the other business is attended to, the Court will move on to the main event – the oral arguments regarding marriage equality.
The argument is being heard in two parts, each part based on the questions the Court wanted answered:
Part 1: The Marriage Question:
During the first half of the hearing, the Court will consider the “marriage” question. One attorney – Mary Bonauto, a longtime LGBTQ rights advocate – will represent all of the petitioners and she will get to make her argument first. Bonauto will get 30 of the 45 minutes given to the petitioners but will probably only speak for 25 of those minutes so she can preserve some time for a rebuttal (counter argument) after the respondent’s attorney makes his case. Bonauto will get an assist from Solicitor General Don Verrilli (the federal government’s top lawyer at the Supreme Court) who will speak for an additional 15 minutes on behalf of the petitioners.
Representing the 4 states (aka the respondents) will be John Bursch, the former solicitor general of Michigan. He also has 45 minutes to argue the state’s side, but he is not entitled to rebut after the petitioner’s counter argument.
After Bursch is finished presenting the respondent’s side of the case, Mary Bonauto will have a chance to respond to and rebut the arguments put forth by Bursch.
Part 2. The Recognition Question:
In the second half, the Court will spend 1 hour of oral arguments on the “recognition” question. The petitioners will be represented by attorney Douglas Hallward-Driemeier and the respondents will be represented by Joseph Whalen. Each attorney will have 30 minutes to argue the recognition question although the petitioner’s attorney may want to save a few minutes of his time to counter the arguments put forth by the respondent’s attorney.
When the petitioner’s attorney is finished with his rebuttal the Chief Justice will officially end the hearing.
Although the oral arguments will be over, the show will continue outside on the Court’s plaza, where LGBTQ advocates will face off with the shrinking anti-marriage faction. I’s a huge case with national implications so there will no doubt be a media circus as well.
All in all it should be an awesome spectacle!
Be sure to visit Rainbow Law’s Facebook Page on Tuesday where we will live-blog the oral arguments as they happen. And make sure you sign up for our newsletter so you can receive up-to-date information about your legal rights.